Eight Men Out (20th Anniversary Edition) DVD
Amazon Products

 Rating: - A great movie about baseball's most fragile moment
Until the nineteen seventies, major league baseball players were held in a form of bondage. They could be bought, sold, traded largely against their will and their salaries were fixed artificially low. The reserve clause in their contracts bound them to that team and prevented them from playing for anyone else without explicit permission. If a player's salary was low, their only recourse was to not play, which was a drastic and self-destructive step.
The treatment of players in the early twentieth century was often even worse, and there was no more ruthless owner than Charles Comiskey. His salary structure for his quality players was much lower than what existed in the rest of major league baseball. He even let his players take the field in dirty uniforms in order to save on laundry bills. Over and over again he lied to his players and failed to pay them promised bonuses. Therefore, baseball historians rightfully blame him for creating the circumstances that led to the 1919 Chicago White Sox team throwing the World Series. That ruthless desire to save money at all costs on the part of Comiskey is captured in this movie.
The inner machinations of the players on the 1919 team are also captured very well. Only a few players were guilty of acts of commission designed to throw the series, others simply knew about it and said nothing to team officials. There was also a great deal of internal dissension on the team, which further inflamed the players. All eight of the players who knew of the conspiracy were banned from baseball for life, even though they were acquitted at trial.
The two people who were most unfairly treated were Shoeless Joe Jackson and Buck Weaver. While both knew about the scheme to throw the series, both played very well in the series, hitting over .300 and playing flawlessly in the field. The Jackson character is played very well in this movie; by all accounts he was a naïve man who really didn't understand the ramifications of what was going on around him. Weaver tried defending himself as best he could against the charges and tried to get reinstated, but the commissioner was adamant against clemency.
A great deal of time is taken in this movie to set the historical backdrop of the 1919 World Series, which is necessary. While the White Sox players did throw the series, in this movie they are presented in a sympathetic light, as men who were poorly treated and just wanted a chance to earn what they felt was their right to have. It is a very good movie about the history of baseball.

Search: